top of page
Home: Welcome
New Train Logo copy.png

With Jonathan Sayre

  • Facebook - White Circle
  • YouTube - White Circle
  • Instagram - White Circle
  • Twitter - White Circle
  • TikTok

Join host Jonathan Sayre and his numerous co-hosts and guests as they dig deep into the unsolved, mind-blowing mysteries of the world, with a comedic twist!
Past co-hosts and guests:
Logan Sayre
Mr. Moody
Jeff Butchko
Riley Sayre
Oliver "Chainsaw" Gimmel
Chris Urminski
and more!


The Midnight Train is restricted to 18+ as we bring you topics surrounding the creepy, the unsolved, and the mysterious with a plethora of dark humor and adult subject matter.

As Vaguely Seen On 




Nailed it!

The JD8 case was the first I heard on your podcast. As a person that lives 15-20 minutes away & remember these murders- seems like you guys nailed the crazy down here! There’s so much more to the case! I can’t wait to see if you guys look into any of the other stuff we have in the bayou!! Especially some of the others that are “suspected” to be related. 

CuJo Preston Spain

Love your show

Hey guys. My name is Preston from Dinwiddie, Virginia now residing in Salt Lake City, Utah. I’ve listened to yours guys show for a little while now especially since I’ve come back home from over seas. I just finished my 8 years in the VA National Guard as an infantryman and every since then I’ve never been huge on podcasts really I started listening to you guys. You are absolutely fun to listen to and I laugh everytime. I do have a story on a creature called the Hellhound when I was in Pennsylvania back in 2014 that changed my perspective on paranormal or mythical creatures. If you like to hear my story please let me. Thank you guys for doing what you do. And Jon im visiting Columbus at the end of May for a family thing and want to know your bars name to raise a glass to you, Moody, and the whole crew. Thanks guys


Hilarious take on horror and true crime!

Adore this show!


Love this podcast!

I love the combination of horror and comedy, can’t wait for the next episode to come out!


Climb aboard the BONUS train and receive exclusive bonus content like video specials, bonus episodes, and we'll mention your name at the end of EVERY episode. Hell, we'll donate a percentage of every Patreon subscription to a specific charity, each month!

bottom of page